What is Socrates argument against Thrasymachus?
Thrasymachus agrees to this, and also to Socrates’ claim that a craftsperson is wise and good, which makes sense at least with respect to the craft in question.
The Outdoing Argument (1.348b–350d)
|Socrates:||Do you call one of the two a virtue and the other a vice?|
|Thrasymachus:||I certainly do. (1.348c–e)|
What does Socrates say about Thrasymachus definition of justice?
What, he says, is Thrasymachus’ definition of justice? Thrasymachus says that he will provide the answer if he is provided his fee. He then says that justice is whatever is in the interest of the stronger party in a given state; justice is thus effected through power by people in power.
What is Socrates argument that justice is more powerful than injustice?
Man’s virtue herein is his justice; it enables him to live well in harmony with others and to be happy. Only justice can bring happiness. Injustice at whatever level brings chaos, discord, unhappiness. In thus producing happiness, justice may be said to be more profitable than injustice.
Do you think Thrasymachus is convinced by Socrates that injustice can never pay better than justice?
Good one, Socrates. Besides, Socrates isn’t convinced by Thrasymachus’s reasoning; he doesn’t believe that injustice is more profitable than justice, and he wants Thrasymachus to prove his point. Thrasymachus says that if Socrates wasn’t persuaded already, he can’t say anything more to convince him.
How does Socrates refute Thrasymachus definition of justice quizlet?
What arguments does Socrates use to refute this definition? Thrasymachus defines justice as nothing more than the advantage of the stronger. Justice is the interest of the stronger. He asks if the art of something is superior to its’ own subject.
What does Thrasymachus say about perfect justice and perfect injustice?
In the first book of the Republic, Thrasymachus attacks Socrates’ position that justice is an important good. He claims that ‘injustice, if it is on a large enough scale, is stronger, freer, and more masterly than justice‘ (344c).
What exactly does Thrasymachus mean by the stronger in other words who is he referring to ?)?
The name Thrasymachus means fierce fighter, and this certainly represents the character of the same name, who appears in book one of Plato’s Republic. Thrasymachus enters Plato’s world with a statement designed to shock, stating that “justice is the advantage of the stronger”.
Why does Socrates believe it is more profitable to be just rather than unjust?
Socrates makes his point that money is not more valuable than the happiness that comes from living well. This means that, even though, the unjust can get more money and power in the expense of true happiness.