What does Thomson say about the Trolley Problem?

In “The Trolley Problem,” Thomson offered a solution—call this her First Solu- tion—according to which the bystander may flip the switch in Bystander be- cause were he to do so (1) he makes what was threatening five come to threaten only one and (2) he does so not by any means that constitute an infringement of any …

Would Kant push the man off the bridge?

A Kantian would still not push the man, regardless of whether he’s a villain or Mother Theresa. An Utilitarian would still push the man, but not because he’s a villain, rather because of the maximization of utility.

What the Trolley Problem says about you?

The trolley problem highlights a fundamental tension between two schools of moral thought. The utilitarian perspective dictates that most appropriate action is the one that achieves the greatest good for the greatest number.

What is the correct answer to the trolley problem?

Foot’s own response to the Trolley Problem was that the morally justified action would be to steer the trolley to kill the one workman, thus saving a net four lives. In order to demonstrate the morality of this, she made a distinction between what she called ‘negative duties’ and ‘positive duties’.

How does Thomson argue that pushing the fat man is impermissible?

In short, she seems to be ADMITTING that pushing the fat man off of the bridge is merely an instance of re-distributing a pre-existing threat. But, it’s still impermissible because you re-distribute the threat via an action that violates his rights.

Who proposed the trolley problem?

Philippa Foot

Philippa Foot, a philosopher who argued that moral judgments have a rational basis, and who introduced the renowned ethical thought experiment known as the Trolley Problem, died at her home in Oxford, England, on Oct.

What does the Trolley Problem teach us Reddit?

“The trolley dilemma allows us to think through the consequences of an action and consider whether its moral value is determined solely by its outcome.”

Why the Trolley Problem is ethically significant?

Why is the trolley problem important? The trolley problem is important because versions of it have been used to explore the validity and range of application of the doctrine of double effect and the distinction between doing harm and allowing harm.

Why is the trolley problem a problem?

Trolley problems highlight the difference between deontological and consequentialist ethical systems. The central question that these dilemmas bring to light is on whether or not it is right to actively inhibit the utility of an individual if doing so produces a greater utility for other individuals.

Is utilitarianism a philosophy?

Understanding Utilitarianism

Utilitarianism is a tradition of ethical philosophy that is associated with Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, two late 18th- and 19th-century British philosophers, economists, and political thinkers.

What is the basis of morality according to Kant?

Kant believed that the shared ability of humans to reason should be the basis of morality, and that it is the ability to reason that makes humans morally significant. He, therefore, believed that all humans should have the right to common dignity and respect.

What is kantianism vs utilitarianism?

The main difference between Kantianism and Utilitarianism is that Kantianism is a deontological moral theory whereas utilitarianism is a teleological moral theory. Both Kantianism and utilitarianism are ethical theories that express the ethical standard of an action.

What is the fundamental principle of morality according to Kant?

According to Kant, the fundamental principle of morality must be a categorical, rather than a hypothetical imperative, because an imperative based on reason alone is one that is a necessary truth, is a priori, and is one that applies to us because we are rational beings capable of fulfilling our moral obligations.

What is the theory of Immanuel Kant?

Kant’s ethics are organized around the notion of a “categorical imperative,” which is a universal ethical principle stating that one should always respect the humanity in others, and that one should only act in accordance with rules that could hold for everyone.

What is an example of Kant’s moral theory?

For example, if you hide an innocent person from violent criminals in order to protect his life, and the criminals come to your door asking if the person is with you, what should you do? Kantianism would have you tell the truth, even if it results in harm coming to the innocent person.